Andrew Carnegie The Gospel Of Wealth Essay

Gospel Of Wealth Summary

SuperSummary, a modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, offers high-quality study guides that feature detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, quotes, and essay topics.  This one-page guide includes a plot summary and brief analysis of Gospel of Wealth by Andrew Carnegie.

Andrew Carnegie’s “Gospel of Wealth,” an article originally published with the shorter title, “Wealth,” was written in June 1889. In his article, Carnegie discusses how the new upper class has a responsibility to be philanthropic in order to mitigate surplus wealth to address issues of wealth inequality. In a world where money was passed down from father to son, or given to the state to determine how it could best serve the public, Carnegie’s ideas were, for his day, new.

He proposes that society can put the wealth of wealthy class to better use than the state. In addition to asserting that the wealthy should engage in philanthropy, Carnegie uses this space to express his disdain for the idea of spending capital irresponsibly—that is, on opulence and self-gratification. He stipulates that when the wealthy does distribute wealth, it should be in a way that doesn’t promote sloth or drunkenness—or anyone considered unworthy.

Carnegie also argues that there are two types of wealthy person. There is the person who gains wealth through hard work and perseverance. This, he says, is the best type of wealth because the person develops an appreciation for the money. In contrast, those who inherit wealth are more likely to waste their money, spending frivolously. He states that willing one’s entire fortune to charity is likewise no guarantee that it will be properly used, unless that charity is under the direction of the one donating the wealth.

The reason for this, according to Carnegie, is that charitable giving has the potential of keeping the poor poor, thus emphasizing the wealth gap. Instead, he proposes that wealth should be given in a way that creates opportunities for those receiving the financial aid. Then, according to Carnegie, that wealth is not only spent, but produces more wealth, ideally enabling the once poor individual to then encourage someone else to develop wealth.

Another point Carnegie makes in “The Gospel of Wealth”is the benefit of high taxes on estates. He considers a wealthy estate to be a mark of someone who has failed in his responsibility to spread his wealth, and therefore, thinks the State is right to condemn the estate by taxing it heavily. If the wealthy distribute their wealth as Carnegie says they should, then there is no concern over there being enough of an estate to tax. To help this along, he proposes that the wealthy ought to live modestly and that dependents of the wealthy receive only moderate monetary support. Finally, Carnegie states that this is the path to reward at the gates of Paradise.

Andrew Carnegie was born in 1835 in Scotland. By 1890, he was a multi-millionaire. The main reason for this was the way in which Carnegie chose to build his business empire. Rather than try to form a monopoly, Carnegie focused on a particular industry—steel—and concentrated on becoming a powerhouse in the industry. Largely self-educated, Carnegie’s ideas about philanthropy solidified by the time he was thirty-five years old. He began donating his money to help those he felt could benefit the most from the wealth. For example, he donated a public bath to his hometown in Scotland. He didn’t want to be remembered for his wealth after he died—he wanted to be remembered for his actions and his philanthropy. Known as a radical philanthropist, Carnegie is remembered today for both his wealth and his philanthropy.

“Wealth” was first published in 1880 in the North American Review magazine. Due to its success and popularity, it was reprinted with the title “Gospel of Wealth” later in the Pall Mall Gazette. Perhaps some of his popularity from this article came from the notion that Carnegie practiced what he preached. Some of the beneficiaries of his philanthropic mission include several local libraries, Carnegie Hall, the Peace Palace, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, the Carnegie Corporation of New York, Carnegie Institution for Science, Carnegie Trust for the Universities of Scotland, Carnegie Mellon University, Carnegie Hero Fund, and the Carnegie Museums of Pittsburgh. That’s just a sampling of the many organizations and institutions that benefited from his belief in the need to spread his wealth for the betterment of the rest of the rest of the world.

Even though “Gospel of Wealth” was published more than one hundred years ago, the debate over the gap between those in poverty and those holding wealth continues to dominate global economic discussions. Many countries have laws on the books covering monopolies and estate taxes, the same topics Carnegie wrote about in the late nineteenth century. If money breeds power, then Carnegie is an exception to the rule that power corrupts.

Andrew Carnegie On The Gospel Of Wealth

  • Length: 1210 words (3.5 double-spaced pages)
  • Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - More ↓
Andrew Carnegie was born in Dunfermline, Scotland in 1835. His father, Will, was a weaver and a follower of Chartism, a popular movement of the British working class that called for the masses to vote and to run for Parliament in order to help improve conditions for workers. The exposure to such political beliefs and his family's poverty made a lasting impression on young Andrew and played a significant role in his life after his family immigrated to the United States in 1848. Andrew Carnegie amassed wealth in the steel industry after immigrating from Scotland as a boy. He came from a poor family and had little formal education.

The roots of Carnegie's internal conflicts were planted in Dunfermline, Scotland, where he was born in 1835, the son of a weaver and political radical who instilled in young Andrew the values of political and economic equality. His family's poverty, however, taught Carnegie a different lesson. When the Carnegies emigrated to America in 1848, Carnegie determined to bring prosperity to his family. He worked many small jobs which included working for the Pennsylvania Railroad where he first recognized the importance of steel.

With this recognition, he resigned and started the Keystone Bridge Company in 1865. He built a steel-rail mill, and bought out a small steel company. By 1888, he had a large plant. Later on he sold his Carnegie Steel Company to J. P. Morgan's U.S.

Steel Company after a serious, bloody union strike.He saw himself as a hero of working people, yet he crushed their unions. The richest man in the world, he railed against privilege. A generous philanthropist, he slashed the wages of the workers who made him rich. By this time, Carnegie was an established, successful millionaire. He was a great philanthropist, donating over $350 million dollars to public causes, opening libraries, money for teachers, and funds to support peace.

In the end, he gave away about 90% of his own money to various causes. He also preached to others to do the same as in giving money for education and sciences.The problem, however, was that there was such a contrast between the rich and the poor. By this he was referring to the inequalities in rights, hereditary powers, and such things. He also felt we should have a continuum of forward progress, i.e.

civilizing, industrializing.Apparently in his time there was a movement to drift back into a time when there was little advance in modernizing and technologically advancing; when "neither master nor servant was as well situated.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Andrew Carnegie On The Gospel Of Wealth." 13 Mar 2018

LengthColor Rating 
Andrew Carnegie's Gospel of Wealth Essay - Andrew Carnegie's Gospel of Wealth Andrew Carnegie believes in a system based on principles and responsibility. The system is Individualism and when everyone strives towards the same goals the system is fair and prosperous. Carnegie’s essay is his attempt to show people a way to reach an accommodation between individualism and fairness. This system can only work if everyone knows and participates in his or her responsibilities. I will discuss Carnegie’s thesis, his arguments and the possible results of his goals....   [tags: Papers]568 words
(1.6 pages)
Good Essays[preview]
Andrew Carnegie On The Gospel Of Wealth Essay examples - Andrew Carnegie was born in Dunfermline, Scotland in 1835. His father, Will, was a weaver and a follower of Chartism, a popular movement of the British working class that called for the masses to vote and to run for Parliament in order to help improve conditions for workers. The exposure to such political beliefs and his family's poverty made a lasting impression on young Andrew and played a significant role in his life after his family immigrated to the United States in 1848. Andrew Carnegie amassed wealth in the steel industry after immigrating from Scotland as a boy....   [tags: essays research papers]1210 words
(3.5 pages)
Strong Essays[preview]
Andrew Carnegie Essay examples - Andrew Carnegie was born on November 25, 1835 in Dunfermline, the medieval capital of Scotland. His parents were William Carnegie, who was a linen weaver; and Margaret Carnegie, who made shoes. The town of Dunfermline was strongly based in linen weaving, and when the industrial revolution hit, linen workers such as William Carnegie found themselves out of work. Margaret quickly took on additional jobs to help the family, opening a grocery store and fixing shoes. This was an important turning point in Andrew Carnegie's life....   [tags: Gospel of Wealth, Philantropy]
:: 3 Works Cited
1127 words
(3.2 pages)
Strong Essays[preview]
The Distribution of Wealth Essay - Everyone has his or her own ideas of how wealth should be distributed properly. Some people believe wealth should be left to family, left for public services, or become the property of others. Others believe that people should not have excess wealth, resulting in non-existent class distinctions. An alternative view is that wealth is not distributed; instead, the wealthy continue to grow wealthier while those in poverty can not escape it and fall further into a life of poverty. The beliefs discussed above come from three different writers....   [tags: Andrew Carnegie, Karl Marx, Robert B Reich]
:: 3 Works Cited
877 words
(2.5 pages)
Better Essays[preview]
Shakira Meberak and Andrew Carnegie Beliefs Essay - “What we have done for ourselves alone dies with us; what we have done for others and the world remains and is immortal.” (Pike). This is the belief of Shakira Ripoll Meberak and Andrew Carnegie, two paradoxical people that will go down in history for their philanthropy among their other enormous accomplishments. Shakira is a very successful songwriter, dancer and singer, but she has a flipside. A much deeper side than most would expect from such a shallow persona is her charitable side. Carnegie, also has another side to him that made him equally as famous as his huge business skills....   [tags: donations, charities, philanthropy effects]
:: 5 Works Cited
1487 words
(4.2 pages)
Powerful Essays[preview]
Andrew Carnegie Essay - The richest man in the world, in his time, was Andrew Carnegie. His story of success was truly one of rags to riches. After coming to the U.S. from Scotland as part of a working-class family, he moved from job to job, eventually becoming more influential and gaining a large sum of money. Soon he was using his wealth to contribute to many public services, such as libraries and schools. Andrew Carnegie's life and actions have left a long-standing legacy and have contributed greatly to the American way of life, particularly toward education....   [tags: Biography]1718 words
(4.9 pages)
Powerful Essays[preview]
Essay on Andrew Carnegie - Andrew Carnegie Essay In the nineteenth century, when I hear the word Captain of Industry the name Andrew Carnegie comes to mind. Rather than being a Robber Baron, I believe Carnegie deserves the title Captain of Industry for many reasons. One reason would be that he came from being a poor young boy in Scotland, to being one of the richest men in America years after he and his family immigrated to the United States of America. The next reason would be that he provided many of his workers high earnings of money as well as how he funded certain public places....   [tags: Biography]955 words
(2.7 pages)
Strong Essays[preview]
Wealth and Poverty: Karl Marx Essay - Communism has been regarded as the opposite to capitalism; however it was capitalism that gave rise to communism. During the Gilded Age capitalism influenced the growth of the industrial revolution in Europe and in the United States. The Gilded Age was the period of 1870-1910, where there was great economic growth in the United States. People like Andrew Carnegie and John D. Rockefeller were entrepreneurs who made their fortunes in this age of industrialization. Although this period brought technological advances and economic growth, it also was a period of disparity and poverty....   [tags: communism, capitalism, gilded age]
:: 5 Works Cited
1702 words
(4.9 pages)
Powerful Essays[preview]
Andrew Carnegie, Eugene V. Debs, and Horatio Alger Essay - Andrew Carnegie, Eugene V. Debs, and Horatio Alger During the late nineteenth century rapid industrialization paved the way for extreme economical wealth of many business. In accordance with the overflowing wealth in the nineteenth century many individuals held similar but yet contrasting views toward the wealth that was created in the United States. Among these individuals were Andrew Carnegie, Eugene V. Debs, and Horatio Alger. One of the best-known philanthropists was the American industrialist Andrew Carnegie, who devoted the latter part of his life to giving away most of the huge fortune he had amassed in the steel industry....   [tags: essays research papers]560 words
(1.6 pages)
Good Essays[preview]
Wealth Essay - Wealth “The Gospel of Wealth” written by Andrew Carnegie discusses the post Civil War industrial expansion era, a time that produced immense wealth for many business tycoons. Andrew Carnegia, an elite industrialist, created a very large wealth for himself during this time. Some of the elite industrialists tried to change their “robber baron image by curbing their often ostentatious lifestyles and seeking opportunities to enhance the community.” Andrew for one, decided that it was imperative for wealthy individuals to disperse their wealth throughout the society for the advancement of the community....   [tags: essays research papers]464 words
(1.3 pages)
Strong Essays[preview]

Related Searches

Andrew Carnegie         Steel Company         Wealth         Gospel         Significant Role         Formal Education         Economic Equality         Internal Conflicts        

" This proves that the direction the U.S. took until now was, in fact, the right path since the goal was already in progress. He has to argue and prove that through forward motion all of these problems of social difference, that the poor would also advance with the times, thus diminishing the difference slowly but surely. As the rich get richer they bring up the standard and, in effect, the poor with them as the economy grows. The government comes up with a way to run money that is suited to be in the best interest of the most possible people. In the end, you realize that the majority of the wealth made in this new system is going only to a few people.Then it says about the only question that could possibly arise in this type of a situation.

Since the wealth inevitably goes to a concentrated amount of people in the best possible set of circumstances, the question is what to do with the money in order to best serve the general public. So what can a man do with the excess wealth he has amassed? His money is not just for "competence," but rather surplus money. There are three solutions that Carnegie gives for this. The first includes leaving one's money to his family or his oldest son, a common practice in western Europe. This is a "misguided affection", and a bad idea according to Carnegie, because one cannot duplicate the styles and strategies of another no matter how hard he tries.

A son can make mistakes and lose his fortune or he can lose it "from the fall in the value of land." It has also been proven that it is not good for the state for a son to take his father's place as a leader. He could mean that the son has been given all of these treasures from birth and does not appreciate what he is getting. He also may not be sensitive to all that is necessary in the processes of development. Another way one could dispose of surplus wealth is to have all the money earned be spent by the one who earns it. This is not always possible these days and perhaps also back then, because ther is no limit to what one can earn. But spending frivolously just because one can isn't exactly the best trait; one should live in modesty.One other way Carnegie suggests the money could be distributed would be to donate it to public services.

This is the one he personally chose because it serves the most good to most amount of people possible. It is therefore not detrimental to the value of money to others, and is enjoyed by he who earned it - a very fair way of disposal. The objective, however, he wished to achieve may not be achieved after he's gone because he can't oversee the operation of the distribution, and there's nothing he could do about it then. Taxing the hoards of wealth obtained by a recently deceased man is a great way of giving back to the community what was taken over the years. It also condemns the lifestyle of the "selfish millionaire's unworthy life." This helps make men deal with the distribution of their money while they're still alive, with the intent that the best possible solution would be achieved and finding the way that would be "most fruitful for the people." There is only one solution which pleases both rich and poor and works out best for everyone. This idea differs from communistic ideals of spreading wealth evenly throughout, at all times, and doesn't require an overthrow of the government, rather an "evolution of existing conditions." The idea is that each individual work for himself in attaining wealth (as in the concept of laissez-faire); each man fighting for his place, creating competition.

In the end, there will still be a concentration of wealth in a few, but they will spread their wealth to the masses through public services, thus benefiting all, instead of money coming to all people in small increments as suggested by communistic ideas. This appealed to the people especially in the concept of anti-communism sprinkled in Carnegie's document. This also gives concrete evidence proving U.S. superiority in understanding their nation's needs. Finally, there are specific duties of the rich in order to maintain the balance.

The wealthy must be modest in their ways. They must provide modestly for those dependent on him and he must think and administer his money in the best possible manner to benefit the most possible people. We trust in this wealthy man because he obviously became wealthy through superior wisdom, etc.... - This I believe may be immodest, but true nonetheless.

One thought on “Andrew Carnegie The Gospel Of Wealth Essay

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *